| 2020 |
|
| Sam Sommerfeld |
UMHB |
| 2019 |
|
| Lexi Alexander |
SAGU |
| Jordan Tondreau |
LeTourneau |
| Olivia Dunn |
Centenary College |
| Gracey Ford |
TVCC |
| Addison McDermott |
Northwestern State |
| Ashton Brown |
Panola |
| Payton Jones |
Panola |
| Courtlyn Nail |
TJC |
| 2018 |
|
| Allie Fennell |
ETBU |
| Mattison Doffitt |
UMHB |
| Riley Seegers |
Panola College |
| Madison Fite |
Texas Southern University |
| Courtney Edge |
Eastfield College |
| Hannah Humphries |
Millsaps College |
| Shelbi Sheppard |
Texas A&M Commerce |
| 2017 |
|
| Laura Rose Gray |
Mississippi State |
| Kaitlyn Nutt |
Lamar |
| Chelsea Chadwick |
Panola |
| Audrey Slaten |
Panola |
| Faith Landreneaux |
Bethune-Cookman |
| Lauren Almuete |
TVCC |
| Charlotte Bradshaw |
Tarleton State University |
| Regan Humphreys |
SFA |
| Alli Capps |
Southeastern Louisiana University |
| Molly Harris |
Panola |
| Alexis Wiley |
Lamar |
| 2016 |
|
| Ann Hollas |
SFA |
| Rhyan Rand |
University of New Orleans |
| Camie Copeland |
Panola |
| Cayman Sutton |
Panola |
| Kaitlyn Adams |
Panola |
| Kayla McCoy |
UT-Tyler |
| Erin McCallum |
ETBU |
| 2014 |
|
| Zhanelle Geathers |
The University of Texas at Arlington |
| Katelynn Meadows |
St Gregory's |
| Rebecca Green |
East Texas Baptist University |
| Alyssa Auringer |
TVCC |
| Mackenzie Tate |
TVCC |
| Madison Sampson |
Panola College |
| Carly Dyess |
Panola College |
| Iesha Bryant |
The University of Tennessee |
| 2013 |
|
| Savannah Voelzke |
University of Arkansas |
| Dorothy Swanson |
Abilene Christian University |
| Mallory Kuechle |
TWU |
| Katie Brolo |
University of Texas at Tyler |
| Alexis Crowder |
Richland College |
| Devyn Hooten |
Ranger College |
| 2012 |
|
| Abbey Bybel |
SMU |
| Whitney Ford |
Texas Tech |
| Kalloway Hudson |
East Texas Baptist University |
| Kaci Jackson |
Arkansas Tech |
| Darby Graff |
Texas A&M/Arkansas State |
| 2011 |
|
| Lauren McCallum |
East Texas Baptist University |
| Emily Todd |
Arkansas Tech |
| Lacy Hodges |
Tarleton State |
| Taryn Dyess |
UT-Tyler |
| Hillary Shaffer |
TWU |
| Kelci Lind |
TWU |
| Kaitlyn White |
Arkansas Tech |
