| Year | Player | High School | College/University |
| 1990 | Leslie Harris | Mt. Pleasant | East Texas State |
| 1991 | Shundra Reddic | Tyler Lee | LeTourneau University |
| 1992 | Cynthia Cook | Tyler Lee | Northwest Wyoming |
| Erica Garrett | Eustace | Southern Miss | |
| Sandy Kennedy | Chapel Hill | Northwest Wyoming | |
| April Koonce | Grand Saline | Louisiana Tech | |
| 1993 | Lacreece Allen | Longview | Southern Arkansas |
| Sonya Barnes | Longview | University of Texas | |
| Tracey Giorgio | Tyler Lee | East Texas State | |
| Nikki Holton | Tyler Lee | Washington Univ @ St Louis | |
| 1994 | Tara DeFrancisco | Spring Hill | LeTourneau University |
| Casey Fleener | Hallsville | SFA | |
| April Taylor | Marshall | SFA | |
| Heather Brown | Lindale | Southeast Louisiana | |
| 1995 | Lisa Evans | Pine Tree | Alvin Junior College |
| P.J. Poe | Quitman | Vernon Junior College | |
| Chandra Robertson | Hallsville | Texas A & M | |
| Olivia Sadler | Alba-Golden | SMU | |
| Lindsey Sheppard | Texas High | Louisiana Tech | |
| Crystal Vaught | Rusk | LeTourneau University | |
| LaKita Graham | Longview | UNT | |
| Leslie McGee | Pine Tree | John Brown University | |
| 1996 | Ginger Capello | Lindale | Hill College |
| Carmen Eckhart | Longview | Hill College | |
| Jennifer McCraven | Spring Hill | East Texas Baptist University | |
| Keisha Powell | Longview | Panola College | |
| Amy Underwood | Hallsville | Louisiana Tech | |
| Lana Fishback | Lindale | Univ. of Northern Alabama | |
| Ginger Dunlap | Lindale | Austin College | |
| 1997 | Amanda Arnold | Hallsville | Louisiana Tech |
| Lasandra Beasley | Gilmer | Eastfield College | |
| Kelli Fitzpatrick | Tyler Lee | Louisiana Tech | |
| Kate Kissel | T.K. Gorman | Yale | |
| Jennifer Klimiuk | Marshall | Cameron University | |
| Janna Marshall | Marshall | Centenary | |
| Amy Goleman | Pine Tree | John Brown University | |
| Susan Newton | Carthage | Panola College | |
| Carissa Rae | Hallsville | Panola College | |
| Stephanie Carwile | Hallsville | Coker College | |
| 1998 | Casey Dennard | Carthage | Panola College |
| Lisa Ham | Carthage | Panola College | |
| Windy Wilson | Pine Tree | University of South Dakota | |
| Fiorella Giordano | Christian Heritage | TJC | |
| Jennifer Smith | Pine Tree | Ouachita Baptist | |
| Trudy Baker | White Oak | Jacksonville College | |
| Adrian Munns | White Oak | Ouachita Baptist | |
| Nicole McCray | Pine Tree | University of Florida | |
| Cara Wonders | Pine Tree | Texas Womens University | |
| Kristee Porter | John Tyler | UCLA | |
| 1999 | Julie Tarnawa | Pine Tree | Univ. of Louisiana Monroe |
| Melissa Mortis | Whitehouse | University of Texas | |
| Kristen Sheppard | Texas High | Baylor | |
| Terri Shurtleff | Hallsville | Henderson St. | |
| Alison Tuttle | Texas High | Lamar University | |
| Jennifer Smith | Tyler Lee | Belhaven College | |
| Gina Nelson | Tyler Lee | TJC | |
| 2000 | Natalie Shipp | Big Sandy | Panola / Louisiana Tech |
| Whitney Edens | Beckville | Galveston College | |
| Mia Hooper | Carthage | TJC | |
| Lacy Lewis | Spring Hill | Central Arkansas | |
| Felica Taylor | Prairiland | Lamar University | |
| Jennifer Jones | Hallsville | Southeastern Louisiana | |
| Sherrin Walker | Marshall | Panola College | |
| 2001 | Lyndsay Simpson | Pine Tree | Panola / ETBU |
| Katie Crowder | Pleasant Grove | McNeese | |
| Nicole James | White Oak | McNeese | |
| Aneita Sammons | Tatum | Panola College | |
| LaTasha Jacobs | Pine Tree | Texas State | |
| 2002 | Danin Anthony | Tatum | TJC |
| Cara Causey | Pine Tree | LSU | |
| Tamara McFarland | Overton | Panola College | |
| Jessica Philpott | Pine Tree | TJC | |
| Haley Van Syckle | New Diana | Richland College | |
| Samantha Zentz | Gladewater | Texas A&M Commerce | |
| 2003 | Britney Davis | Tyler Lee | Ouachita Baptist |
| Amber McCray | Pine Tree | University of Florida | |
| Jamie Hamman | Grand Saline | TJC | |
| Chelsea Rowe | Carthage | Panola College | |
| Amanda Schwartz | Pleasant Grove | Henderson State | |
| Katie Travers | Tyler Lee | Panola College | |
| Korey Fondel | Longview | Xavier University | |
| Brittany Gray | Hallsville | CVCC | |
| Camille Jamerson | Longview | Butler University | |
| Breann Mcllhenny | Tatum | UT-Tyler | |
| Kelly Roberts | Quitman | UT-Tyler | |
| Tenesha Robinson | Longview | TJC | |
| LaShonda Roberts | Longview | Dillard | |
| 2004 | Melissa Jones | Hallsville | Southeastern Louisiana |
| Deidra Allen | Pine Tree | NCTC | |
| Amy Clendenin | Pine Tree | NCTC | |
| Briana Smith | Pleasant Grove | SWCC | |
| Cidney Legg | Arp | Redlands College | |
| Carrie Buchanan | Carthage | MIT | |
| 2005 | Lauren Secord | White Oak | Panola College / Dallas Baptist |
| Madeline Craven | White Oak | Texas Women's University | |
| Keisha Raibon | Pine Tree | Univ. of Louisian Monroe/NC State | |
| Paige Edens | Beckville | Panola College | |
| Hannah Toole | Whitehouse | Hardin-Simmons | |
| April Manshack | Carthage | Panola College | |
| Ashley Beeman | White Oak | Howard Payne University | |
| 2006 | Shawn Williams | Longview | Prairie View A&M |
| Hunter Howell | Pine Tree | Tulsa | |
| Jessica Crow | Pine Tree | Texas Womens University | |
| Michelle Manningham | Longview Christian | Panola College | |
| Rebekah Hill | Carthage | Centenary | |
| 2007 | Erin Fondel | Longview | Prairie View A&M |
| Adrienne Tillery | Carthage | Oklahoma City University | |
| Brittani Youman | Tatum | UNT | |
| 2008 | Dena Busse | Harmony | Panola College |
| Kiara Jordan | Gilmer | Midwestern | |
| Chelsea Manningham | Longview Christian | TJC | |
| Lindsey Shipp | Harmony | Panola College | |
| Mary Morgan Swanson | White Oak | East Texas Baptist University | |
| 2011 | Lauren McCallum | Diana | East Texas Baptist University |
| Kelci Lind | Lindale | Incarnate Word | |
| Emily Todd | Longview | Navarro | |
| Kaitlyn White | Lindale | Arkansas Tech | |
| Taryn Dyess | Troup | UT-Tyler | |
| Lacy Hodges | Gilmer | Tarleton State University |